• Skip to Content
  • Skip to Main Navigation
  • Skip to Search

Indiana University Bloomington Indiana University Bloomington IU Bloomington

Open Search
  • The Program
    • Advisory Board
    • Interdisciplinary Dual PhD Program in CNS
    • Minor and Affiliates
    • Faculty and Staff
    • Coursework
      • Coursework for Complex Networks and Systems
      • Domain-specific Programs
        • Domain-specific PhD in Cognitive Science
        • Domain-specific PhD in Neuroscience
        • Domain-specific PhD in Psychology and Brain Sciences
        • Domain-specific PhD in Political
        • Domain-specific PhD in Sociology
        • Dual PhD with Additional Programs
      • Research Rotation Courses for the CNS-NRT trainees
      • Extended Colloquium Series
      • CNS-NRT trainees and affiliates participate in an NRT-supported research internships.
    • Perks of being in the CNS-NRT
  • Research
    • Research Efforts
      • Social Network Science
      • Network Neuroscience
      • Health and Health Care
      • Science of Science
      • Other Research Efforts
    • Professional Development
    • Publications
  • How to Apply
  • Students
    • Affiliates
      • 2019 Affiliates
      • 2019 Affiliates
      • 2018 Affiliates
    • Trainees
      • 2020 Trainees
      • 2019 Trainees
      • 2018 Trainees
      • 2017 Trainees
  • colloquia
  • News
  • Resources
  • Twitter

Interdisciplinary Training in
Complex Networks and Systems

  • Home
  • The Program
    • Advisory Board
    • Interdisciplinary Dual PhD Program in CNS
    • Minor and Affiliates
    • Faculty and Staff
    • Coursework
    • Perks of being in the CNS-NRT
  • Research
    • Research Efforts
    • Professional Development
    • Publications
  • How to Apply
  • Students
    • Affiliates
    • Trainees
  • colloquia
  • News
  • Search
  • Resources
  • Twitter
  • Home
  • colloquia
  • Melanie Mitchell

Melanie Mitchell: Artificial Intelligence and the “Barrier of Meaning”

Friday, April 05, 2019

3:00 PM – 4:00 PM

Dorsey Learning Hall (#1106), Luddy Hall
Bloomington, IN

Abstract

In 1986, the mathematician and philosopher Gian-Carlo Rota wrote, “I wonder whether or when artificial intelligence will ever crash the barrier of meaning.”   Here, the phrase “barrier of meaning” refers to a belief about humans versus machines: humans are able to “actually understand” the situations they encounter, whereas AI systems (at least current ones) do not possess such understanding.   The internal representations learned by (or programmed into) AI systems do not capture the rich “meanings” that humans bring to bear in perception, language, and reasoning.   

In this talk I will assess the state of the art of artificial intelligence in several domains, and describe some of their current limitations and vulnerabilities, which can be accounted for by a lack of true understanding of the domains they work in.    I will explore the following questions: (1) To be reliable in human domains, what do AI systems actually need to “understand”?   (2)  Which domains require human-like understanding?  And (3) What does such understanding entail?

Biography

Melanie Mitchell is Professor of Computer Science at Portland State University, and External Professor and Member of the Science Board at the Santa Fe Institute. She attended Brown University, where she majored in mathematics and did research in astronomy, and the University of Michigan, where she received a Ph.D. in computer science, Her dissertation, in collaboration with her advisor Douglas Hofstadter, was the development of Copycat, a computer program that makes analogies. She has held faculty or professional positions at the University of Michigan, the Santa Fe Institute, Los Alamos National Laboratory, the OGI School of Science and Engineering, and Portland State University. She is the author or editor of five books and over 80 scholarly papers in the fields of artificial intelligence, cognitive science, and complex systems. Her most recent book, Complexity: A Guided Tour (Oxford, 2009), won the 2010 Phi Beta Kappa Science Book Award. It was also named by Amazon.com as one of the ten best science books of 2009, and was longlisted for the Royal Society's 2010 book prize. Melanie originated the Santa Fe Institute's Complexity Explorer project, which offers online courses and other educational resources related to the field of complex systems.

Calendar event: https://apps.iu.edu/ccl-prd/EventMaintenance.do?methodToCall=viewEvent&eventId=17892279&pubCalId=GRP1557

CNS-NRT Student Discussion Seminar

  • Lead: Prof. Rob Goldstone
  • Date/Time: April 1st at 2pm
  • Location: NRT shared space conferene room

Papers to be discussed

  • Melanie Mitchell (2018) Artificial Intelligence Hits the Barrier of Meaning. Opinion, The New York Times.
  • Max H. Quinn, Erik Conser, Jordan M. Witte and Melanie Mitchell (2017) Semantic Image Retrieval via Active Grounding of Visual Situations. arXiv: 1711.00088.

Photos

Melanie Mitchel's Talk in the CNS-NRT Interdisciplinary Program at IU
Melanie Mitchel's Talk in the CNS-NRT Interdisciplinary Program at IU
Melanie Mitchel's Talk in the CNS-NRT Interdisciplinary Program at IU
Melanie Mitchel's Talk in the CNS-NRT Interdisciplinary Program at IU
Melanie Mitchel's Talk in the CNS-NRT Interdisciplinary Program at IU
Melanie Mitchel's Talk in the CNS-NRT Interdisciplinary Program at IU
Melanie Mitchel's Talk in the CNS-NRT Interdisciplinary Program at IU
Melanie Mitchel's Talk in the CNS-NRT Interdisciplinary Program at IU
Melanie Mitchel's Talk in the CNS-NRT Interdisciplinary Program at IU
Melanie Mitchel's Talk in the CNS-NRT Interdisciplinary Program at IU
Melanie Mitchel's Talk in the CNS-NRT Interdisciplinary Program at IU
Melanie Mitchel's Talk in the CNS-NRT Interdisciplinary Program at IU
Melanie Mitchel's Talk in the CNS-NRT Interdisciplinary Program at IU
Melanie Mitchel's Talk in the CNS-NRT Interdisciplinary Program at IU

Interdisciplinary Training in Complex Networks and Systems resources and social media channels

  • Twitter

Indiana University

Accessibility | Privacy Notice | Copyright © 2023 The Trustees of Indiana University